boohoohoo

ABC is greatly, greatly softening the severity of what the Prosecution is alleged to have done.

It is much, much worse than just ‘Prosecution accidentally violated his HIPAA rights’.

https://www.courthousenews.com/luigi-mangione-accuses-prosecutors-of-fudging-subpoena-for-his-health-records/

“The district attorney falsely made up a court date — May 23, 2025 — and drafted a fraudulent subpoena that if Aetna did not provide documents on that date, it would be in contempt of court,” Mangione claims in a New York Supreme document, filed Thursday.

(In legalese, ‘Mangione claims’ means that his lawyers claim this in an exhaustive report/complaint to the judge of this case.)

The Prosecution appears to have served Aetna with a literally fake, fradulent subpoena.

That subpoena included a court date which was never actually scheduled in the court system.

…

You cannot do this.

Any request for a subpoena like this has to go through and be approved by the judge.

Circumventing the judge and essentially falsely acting on a fraudulent representation of their authority is actually potentially a crime, bare minimum, something a lawyer can be disbarred for.

And this is the District Attorney of New York leading the legal team against Mangione, whom Mangione’s Defense Counsel has now formally accused of doing this.

Mangione’s counsel has requested to the Judge that, bare minimum, whoever on the Prosecution team is actually responsible for this be removed from the rest of the proceedings, ideally, have the entire trial be dismissed as a mistrial.

…

Here is the entire complaint to the Judge from Mangione’s Defense Counsel:

https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/mangione-hippa-defense-filing.pdf

…

This could actually blow up at least this New York State level case against Mangione.

…

There are currently two simultaneous cases going on, one at the New York State level, one at the Federal level, all of this is irt the NY case.