Sure, but sometimes (a lot of the time, from the experiences of multiple women in my life) doctors use “you’re overweight” as a thought terminating phrase and won’t even begin to look at other possible illnesses or treatments other than “you’re overweight, you need diet and exercise”.
By all means, if obesity is impacting their health it is something that needs to be addressed as well. That doesn’t negate other health issues that happen to be comorbid with obesity, though.
Regardless of gender, this is where doctors go if you are obese, because most of the time, it’s because you are obese.
Then of the patients that insist the obesity has nothing to do with it, some of them are right but the majority of those skeptics are wrong and just won’t do the diet and exercise. It’s hard if you try to take every one of those doubts seriously at first only to ultimately confirm the initial diagnosis over and over again in the patients they give a benefit of the doubt to.
Body positivity was a warranted reaction to the drive to be underweight, but obesity is too far the other way. Being a touch ‘overweight’ while also being reasonably active seems to be the sweet spot health wise, but obesity can produce just all sorts of health issues that people don’t want to admit are related.
This isn’t about body positivity. They can still be obese and need to lose weight. They can have other health conditions directly and immediately caused by being overweight. But there is an all too real and all too common experience of doctors refusing to even consider other ailments simply because the patient is obese.
That is not okay. Even if they see a hundred patients a day where their issues are only caused by being obese, they cannot be allowed to fall into the mindset where that is what they immediately assume.
Yes, if obesity is impacting their health. Obesity may be putting them at higher risk for certain conditions and diseases, and is putting extra strain on their bodies, but that should not impact a medical professional’s complete diagnosis. This is how people suffer and/or die from otherwise treatable conditions.
Sometimes obesity is a symptom of something else wrong that doesn’t get diagnosed, it’s a systemic issue sadly.
However I do wish I could shame the overweight people buying enough snacks for a family as their midnight snack. Like honey, this is why you’re big, have you tried just not eating four candy bars a day?
Funny thing, I do keep my mouth shut and just don’t, I wish trans phobia would get people barking as much as hypothetical fat phobia. (Which right now, is just ONE)
Maybe my cPTSD is what’s wrong with me, fucking tired of being fat treated with more respect than being transgender.
If this was reddit, I could also expect pushback for bringing up being trans while “not being relevant”
I am also against transphobia. You can care about multiple things, it isn’t either/or. There are indeed fat trans people too. And respect and love given to someone else doesn’t mean you can’t also have it.
Actually, I’ll elaborate on this and we will see where it goes.
Abusers are intersectional and thus the abuse victims receive is intersectional, as it is projection. Abuse requires little-n narcissism. People can be narcissistic about certain things, which cause delusions that are literally inflammatory and agitating. These delusions inform the “type” of narcissist, who needs confirmation for the delusions (called narcissistic supply) to soothe the inflammation reality provides when their delusions fail to match.
Narcissists with their friends or family who are enforcing delusions and getting supply as a condition of their relationship are known as abusive relationships. Narcissists grouped together in large bodies are known as cults - abusive interpersonal dynamics scaled up. Narcissists grouped together for the purpose of political movements is fascism.
Another name for transphobia is gender fascism. It is directly related to cults (eg Christofascism) and interpersonal abusive relationships. That dad sending you nasty messages is probably some transkid’s abusive dad. They look for people sensitive to their abuse (usually with a history of same type of abuse) to inflict narcissistic abuse on, because the distress of their victim validates the delusions and gives supply.
Another name for ableism is physical narcissism/physical fascism. Controlling other people’s weight with shame and abuse etc is an example. Projecting feelings onto them about their weight being disgusting or bad is another example. Making up a narrative that fat people’s existence and acceptance means transphobia somehow is worse is a delusion. It may feel comforting and give supply, but it’s not real. It’s a story.
One person may not be a physical narcissist, but a transphobe, and vice versa. Someone may be neither, but a racial narcissist. Narcissism isn’t a disease, it is a belief set btw. It is as contagious as hearing the word of God or seeing a meme, because it is a belief set.
What you likely crave is freedom from narcissistic abuse. Rec book Stop Caretaking the Borderline or Narcissist, can be used on your self to help with narcissistic thinking habits that create delusions. Our entire society is narcissistic because advertisements inflame them and so do cheap shitty shows like Tucker Carlson etc. If you have cPTSD, that is on the dissociative spectrum with borderline personality disorder, often caused by narcissistic abuse. Unlearning and disagreeing with narcissistic belief sets will improve/treat your cPTSD if from that.
Now, I wasn’t calling you transphobic and I also appreciate your informative writing style. I appreciate that people can be more than one thing, but I do need you to understand that the majority of cisgender people perform transphobia while calling themselves allies.
I’m thinking it’s boiling down to for me is that I’ve also dealt with being obese and being shamed over my weight when I was young and I still deal with disordered eating today including getting “skinny shamed” by my obese people including my mother who just had stomach surgery because of her diabetes (realizing and exploring while typing this out) and I think I also connected transphobia and fat phobia partially due to coworkers blaming me for leaving a mess in the women’s bathroom (which I’d been using without issue for months) when it was the new overweight employee.
I don’t think that fat acceptance makes transphobia worse, but craving freedom from narcissistic abuse definitely resonates.
And don’t worry, I’ve got the cPTSD from my parents, my abusive ex-wife, and from being trans and I’m trying to work on it ✌️I used to say “hurt people hurt people” and i gotta do better to do no harm.
Yes, there’s gender narcissists and full blown gender fascism in the US now, I 100% agree with you that most cis people are gender narcissists, whether implicit or explicit.
Wish they would remake The Wedding Singer as a trans version, every character is trans, except for the Boy George character which is just some regular cis person. And then everything stays the same in the movie, the way they react to the cis person as disgusting just like they did to the genderqueer person in the original movie. Lol. A girl can dream.
Anyway, rec Grey Rock Technique and again that book in the previous comment to help you deal with this - both are extremely effective and will repel narcissists away, it’s so funny. Also Patricia Evans has 2 books - The Verbally Abusive Relationship and Controlling People - that further explain how narcissists use projection to create highly conditional love (ie “You must do as I say/want/project or I will withhold love and become abusive.”).
Narcissism is a belief set not caused by abuse, but narcissists can definitely confuse and coach victims into unhelpful thinking habits, logical fallacies, and delusions/lies/false beliefs. Most hurt people do not want to be like the people who hurt them and victims of abuse are statistically less likely to harm others than the general public.
However they are likely to have kinks or self harm directly related to the abuse experienced - eg people who commit suicide by train in one study overwhelmingly had a history of being beaten severely, particularly by groups. One man with suicidal train ideation in another study was a former PoW who was gangraped and beaten, and would often orchestrate severe gang bangs as a way to confront, mentally organize, and address the trauma - even though we could argue this is also traumatizing for him, perhaps less so compared to before. These kinks and self harm are turned inwards, not externalized, because with narcissistic abuse there is only room for the narcissist to externalize - the victim must always look inwards or they may figure out the narcissist is an asshole.
Ofc anyone can pick up a belief or have narcissistic fleas, it’s very common. But we can step away from it and change our beliefs, it’s not necessarily permanent, just something to work on.
Systemic issues can affect the amount and quality of both calories and exercise in people’s lives though, so they can at least contribute to obesity. Especially when we’re talking about industrial food production.
While this is definitely true, and I’m very aware of many of those issues personally, I don’t believe that the customers dropping $30 on candy and soda every night at a gas station have the inability to go to the 24/7 grocery down the street for healthier more satiating food
Sure, but sometimes (a lot of the time, from the experiences of multiple women in my life) doctors use “you’re overweight” as a thought terminating phrase and won’t even begin to look at other possible illnesses or treatments other than “you’re overweight, you need diet and exercise”.
By all means, if obesity is impacting their health it is something that needs to be addressed as well. That doesn’t negate other health issues that happen to be comorbid with obesity, though.
Exactly this
Regardless of gender, this is where doctors go if you are obese, because most of the time, it’s because you are obese.
Then of the patients that insist the obesity has nothing to do with it, some of them are right but the majority of those skeptics are wrong and just won’t do the diet and exercise. It’s hard if you try to take every one of those doubts seriously at first only to ultimately confirm the initial diagnosis over and over again in the patients they give a benefit of the doubt to.
Body positivity was a warranted reaction to the drive to be underweight, but obesity is too far the other way. Being a touch ‘overweight’ while also being reasonably active seems to be the sweet spot health wise, but obesity can produce just all sorts of health issues that people don’t want to admit are related.
This isn’t about body positivity. They can still be obese and need to lose weight. They can have other health conditions directly and immediately caused by being overweight. But there is an all too real and all too common experience of doctors refusing to even consider other ailments simply because the patient is obese.
That is not okay. Even if they see a hundred patients a day where their issues are only caused by being obese, they cannot be allowed to fall into the mindset where that is what they immediately assume.
You could’ve stopped after the first word.
Also, “if obesity is impacting their health” is delusional talk. Obesity always impacts health. There is no if.
Yes, if obesity is impacting their health. Obesity may be putting them at higher risk for certain conditions and diseases, and is putting extra strain on their bodies, but that should not impact a medical professional’s complete diagnosis. This is how people suffer and/or die from otherwise treatable conditions.
Yes exactly
Sometimes obesity is a symptom of something else wrong that doesn’t get diagnosed, it’s a systemic issue sadly.
However I do wish I could shame the overweight people buying enough snacks for a family as their midnight snack. Like honey, this is why you’re big, have you tried just not eating four candy bars a day?
All my PCOS sisters (and PCOS brothers with ovaries), raise your hands!
Is there something fucking wrong with you that you want to put your shame and fat phobia onto others minding their own business?
Funny thing, I do keep my mouth shut and just don’t, I wish trans phobia would get people barking as much as hypothetical fat phobia. (Which right now, is just ONE)
Maybe my cPTSD is what’s wrong with me, fucking tired of being fat treated with more respect than being transgender.
If this was reddit, I could also expect pushback for bringing up being trans while “not being relevant”
I am also against transphobia. You can care about multiple things, it isn’t either/or. There are indeed fat trans people too. And respect and love given to someone else doesn’t mean you can’t also have it.
Actually, I’ll elaborate on this and we will see where it goes.
Abusers are intersectional and thus the abuse victims receive is intersectional, as it is projection. Abuse requires little-n narcissism. People can be narcissistic about certain things, which cause delusions that are literally inflammatory and agitating. These delusions inform the “type” of narcissist, who needs confirmation for the delusions (called narcissistic supply) to soothe the inflammation reality provides when their delusions fail to match.
Narcissists with their friends or family who are enforcing delusions and getting supply as a condition of their relationship are known as abusive relationships. Narcissists grouped together in large bodies are known as cults - abusive interpersonal dynamics scaled up. Narcissists grouped together for the purpose of political movements is fascism.
Another name for transphobia is gender fascism. It is directly related to cults (eg Christofascism) and interpersonal abusive relationships. That dad sending you nasty messages is probably some transkid’s abusive dad. They look for people sensitive to their abuse (usually with a history of same type of abuse) to inflict narcissistic abuse on, because the distress of their victim validates the delusions and gives supply.
Another name for ableism is physical narcissism/physical fascism. Controlling other people’s weight with shame and abuse etc is an example. Projecting feelings onto them about their weight being disgusting or bad is another example. Making up a narrative that fat people’s existence and acceptance means transphobia somehow is worse is a delusion. It may feel comforting and give supply, but it’s not real. It’s a story.
One person may not be a physical narcissist, but a transphobe, and vice versa. Someone may be neither, but a racial narcissist. Narcissism isn’t a disease, it is a belief set btw. It is as contagious as hearing the word of God or seeing a meme, because it is a belief set.
What you likely crave is freedom from narcissistic abuse. Rec book Stop Caretaking the Borderline or Narcissist, can be used on your self to help with narcissistic thinking habits that create delusions. Our entire society is narcissistic because advertisements inflame them and so do cheap shitty shows like Tucker Carlson etc. If you have cPTSD, that is on the dissociative spectrum with borderline personality disorder, often caused by narcissistic abuse. Unlearning and disagreeing with narcissistic belief sets will improve/treat your cPTSD if from that.
Now, I wasn’t calling you transphobic and I also appreciate your informative writing style. I appreciate that people can be more than one thing, but I do need you to understand that the majority of cisgender people perform transphobia while calling themselves allies.
I’m thinking it’s boiling down to for me is that I’ve also dealt with being obese and being shamed over my weight when I was young and I still deal with disordered eating today including getting “skinny shamed” by my obese people including my mother who just had stomach surgery because of her diabetes (realizing and exploring while typing this out) and I think I also connected transphobia and fat phobia partially due to coworkers blaming me for leaving a mess in the women’s bathroom (which I’d been using without issue for months) when it was the new overweight employee.
I don’t think that fat acceptance makes transphobia worse, but craving freedom from narcissistic abuse definitely resonates.
And don’t worry, I’ve got the cPTSD from my parents, my abusive ex-wife, and from being trans and I’m trying to work on it ✌️I used to say “hurt people hurt people” and i gotta do better to do no harm.
Yes, there’s gender narcissists and full blown gender fascism in the US now, I 100% agree with you that most cis people are gender narcissists, whether implicit or explicit.
Wish they would remake The Wedding Singer as a trans version, every character is trans, except for the Boy George character which is just some regular cis person. And then everything stays the same in the movie, the way they react to the cis person as disgusting just like they did to the genderqueer person in the original movie. Lol. A girl can dream.
Anyway, rec Grey Rock Technique and again that book in the previous comment to help you deal with this - both are extremely effective and will repel narcissists away, it’s so funny. Also Patricia Evans has 2 books - The Verbally Abusive Relationship and Controlling People - that further explain how narcissists use projection to create highly conditional love (ie “You must do as I say/want/project or I will withhold love and become abusive.”).
Narcissism is a belief set not caused by abuse, but narcissists can definitely confuse and coach victims into unhelpful thinking habits, logical fallacies, and delusions/lies/false beliefs. Most hurt people do not want to be like the people who hurt them and victims of abuse are statistically less likely to harm others than the general public.
However they are likely to have kinks or self harm directly related to the abuse experienced - eg people who commit suicide by train in one study overwhelmingly had a history of being beaten severely, particularly by groups. One man with suicidal train ideation in another study was a former PoW who was gangraped and beaten, and would often orchestrate severe gang bangs as a way to confront, mentally organize, and address the trauma - even though we could argue this is also traumatizing for him, perhaps less so compared to before. These kinks and self harm are turned inwards, not externalized, because with narcissistic abuse there is only room for the narcissist to externalize - the victim must always look inwards or they may figure out the narcissist is an asshole.
Ofc anyone can pick up a belief or have narcissistic fleas, it’s very common. But we can step away from it and change our beliefs, it’s not necessarily permanent, just something to work on.
Obesity is not a systemic issue, it’s a caloric and exercise issue.
I don’t see the point or humanity in shaming fat people, but I also don’t see the point in soothing ego by coddling.
Systemic issues can affect the amount and quality of both calories and exercise in people’s lives though, so they can at least contribute to obesity. Especially when we’re talking about industrial food production.
While this is definitely true, and I’m very aware of many of those issues personally, I don’t believe that the customers dropping $30 on candy and soda every night at a gas station have the inability to go to the 24/7 grocery down the street for healthier more satiating food